I consistently completely turn off my mobile device when I enter a theater. Not just on silent mode – totally powered down. I state this not from a place of judgment, or in the hope that the ghost of Billy Wilder will return to offer approval. I view it as one of life's small luxuries: for at least ninety minutes, I am completely disconnected. I keep my phone off during the end credits as well. It feels indulgent to stay put as the audience gradually exit, illuminated solely by the scrolling names.
And, lately, by the light of the Letterboxd application.
In excess of millions of users engage with Letterboxd, a film-cataloguing application. Similar to the Criterion Collection, it has evolved into a cultural signifier for a certain breed of tastemaker who promotes new releases and revels in unearthing cinematic treasures. Patrons evaluate and critique films, and the wittiest or most illuminating critiques ascend to the top, encouraging film lovers to craft thoughtful responses.
"Should I fail to get my thoughts out quickly after the credits roll, my reviews are far less lucid and well-put," noted one user.
On a recent visit to the movies, the credits had barely started before the gentleman ahead of me began typing his thoughts. Not far away, a duo lingered, heads bowed, jotting down their individual impressions.
The late film-maker David Lynch once offered wisdom: write down every great idea the very second it occurs to you. If you don't, it could be forgotten, and, in his words: "Forgetting a valuable thought, you feel like you could commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to aspiring film-makers, the same principle fits the act of reviewing.
Josh Stern, a 20-year-old university attendee in New York, without fail composes his reviews from his theater seat.
"Unless I jot down my ideas promptly after the credits roll, my critiques are far less coherent and articulate," he explained. "It requires a bit. I'm not a fast writer, and my significant other gets impatient."
He goes to the movies a great deal – on 182 occasions the previous year – and is on a first-name basis with the cinema employees, who sometimes must usher him out so they can begin cleaning the aisles. He considers it acceptable to milk the closing scroll: "When you purchase a theater ticket, the end titles are part of the film experience."
The platform's most ardent supporters credit the app with rekindling enthusiasm around a struggling movie business, where productions are down and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also boasts the type of user profile brands seek – its primary segment of users is between 18 and 24, followed by 25 to 35.)
Hype generates more hype; much-hyped movies see a surge of activity on Letterboxd shortly following the first showings. The most-liked critique of a recent adaptation – "the novelist succumbed in the 19th century yet this interpretation is still the worst thing that has ever befallen her" – has received more than 50,000 hearts. A separate recent film inspired this juxtaposition to a major artist's documentary: "a famous concert movie left in the dust."
"It's somewhat a habit," commented Ben Glidden, a thirty-three-year-old resident who has a career in marketing. He also chooses to jot down thoughts throughout the end sequence. "Thinking about what you just experienced, right after you saw it, helps with the cinematic journey. It helps you grasp the core ideas of a film. If it produces a sense of comfort, that's hardly something you recall hours later."
He feels most driven to critique a film if it was brilliant – or terrible. For example: he recently watched a sci-fi vehicle. "I was so disappointed by how utterly terrible it was, that I was excited to take out my phone and give it a half-star rating," he said. (This reviewer is a more critical reviewer than other professional critics, who assigned the film three stars, labeling it "smart and entertaining material.")
Dakota Chester, a 28-year-old New Yorker who is in social media, saw a fantasy movie at a neighborhood theater and stayed to write the write-up ("it got five stars"). He has witnessed more egregious conduct: people taking out their phones to review the movie they are in the middle of watching. "That behavior gets on my nerves," he commented.
One of film's most enduring tales recounts a showing of an early motion picture that featured a train pulling into a station. The medium was in its earliest days and – according to this largely discredited anecdote – the shot of a locomotive moving right toward the camera frightened the crowd so much that people ran away screaming.
Many decades later, audience behavior remains just as questionable. It seems, no one knows how to behave in a theater these days, especially when the lights dim: viewers snap photos of the image, bring in strong-smelling food, and, as was reported during a blockbuster summer, at times participate in fights.
Certain people have resorted to social media to argue over the propriety of "Letterboxding" in the end sequence. When one social media user